- 1980: Oglivie, Oliver, Wilson
- 1981: Evans, Henderson, Winfield
- 1982: Jackson, Wilson, Winfield
- 1983: Moseby, Rice, Winfield
- 1984: Armas, Rice, Winfield
- 1985: Bell, Henderson, Winfield
- 1986: Barfield, Bell, Puckett
- 1987: Bell, Evans, Puckett
- 1988: Canseco, Greenwell, Puckett
- 1989: Puckett, Sierra, Yount
- 1990: Burks, Canseco, Henderson
- 1991: Canseco, Carter, Griffey Jr.
- 1992: Carter, González, Puckett
- 1993: Belle, González, Griffey Jr.
- 1994: Belle, Griffey Jr., Puckett
- 1995: Belle, Ramirez, Salmon
- 1996: Belle, González, Griffey Jr.
- 1997: Griffey Jr., González, Justice
- 1998: Belle, González, Griffey Jr.
- 1999: Green, Griffey Jr., Ramirez
- 2000: Erstad, Ordóñez, Ramirez
- 2001: González, Ramirez, Suzuki
- 2002: Anderson, Ordóñez, Williams
- 2003: Anderson, Ramirez, Wells
- 2004: Guerrero, Ramirez, Sheffield
- 2005: Guerrero, Ramirez, Sheffield
- 2006: Dye, Guerrero, Ramirez
- 2007: Guerrero, Ordóñez, Suzuki
- 2008: Hamilton, Quentin, Sizemore
- 2009: Bay, Hunter, Suzuki
- 2010: Bautista, Crawford, Hamilton
- 2011: Bautista, Ellsbury, Granderson
- 2012: Hamilton, Trout, Willingham
- 2013: Hunter, Jones, Trout
- 2014: Bautista, Brantley, Trout
- 2015: Cruz, Martinez, Trout
- 2016: Betts, Trout, Trumbo
- 2017: Judge, Springer, Upton
- 2018: Betts, Martinez, Trout
- 2019: Betts, Springer, Trout
- 2020: Hernández, Jiménez, Trout
- 2021: Hernández, Judge, Mullins
- 2022: Judge, Rodríguez, Trout
- 2023: Robert Jr., Rodríguez, Tucker
- 2024: Judge, Santander, Soto
- 2025: Buxton, Greene, Judge
|